Women in Ministry - Our Position

This topic of women in ministry is currently being debated once again. And it will be fade away as other topics take its place. And then when another well-known pastor/movement/denomination changes their view on women in ministry it will be debated again.

As I've discussed this topic with my wife for many years, it just felt like it was time to state our viewpoint/position. As we also lead a church, will serve as a written doctrinal explanation for those who are interested and/or asking us.

WOMEN IN MINISTRY - OUR POSITION

ROCK OC CHURCH & JOEL 2 GENERATION BLOG/PODCAST

Let's begin by defining a couple of terms being used in this debate:

Complementarianism - the position that while men and women are equally created in the image of God, they have different roles, which have differing authority/responsibility. Headship belongs to men alone, and that this was the way men/women were created and not as a result of the Fall. There are roles that women cannot take, and things that they should not be doing in the life of the church. Historically, this has meant that women cannot serve as ordained leaders in the church and cannot teach/preach to men (they can only teach other women and/or children). I will be calling this position Strict Complementarianism from now on, so as to differentiate it from our position.

Egalitarianism - the position that there are essentially no differences between the male and female genders beyond biological ones. Leadership can be either male or female. Men and women have equal authority, equal opportunity, and equal responsibility. No role or position in the church (or family), including ordained leadership, is limited to men. The concept of headship was a result of the Fall and no longer applies under the New Covenant.

Until recently, I would have described my position as being Complementarian/Egalitarian thinking that there wasn't an actual category to define my convictions. However, as I was doing some research during this current season of debate around the topic of women in ministry, I learned that there were, in fact, some terms being used to describe a position similar to mine.

Soft/Broad or Gift-Based Complementarianism 

Based on what I have always maintained - that men and women have different roles in the Body of Christ (and in the family), but that men and women are equally gifted - I am settling on the term Gift-Based Complementarian to best describe our view. 

As a serious student of Church History, I recognize that aspects of my viewpoint are in fact novel, while other aspects of it date back to the Apostolic era and can be found in the earliest centuries of the Church.

As I have both Strict Complementarian and Egalitarian friends, they are both critical of my position (or would be if they knew all that I believed/practiced). In other words, when one finds themselves in the middle, they will be shot at from both sides!

Gift-Based Complementarianism - a summary

  • Men and women were/are created different beyond merely biological differences. Such differences, while part of God's created design, do not indicate inequality of value or importance. 
  • By God's design, men have been given authority to be the head of the Church (and the family). This means that men and women have been given different authority, where women are to be under the headship of men. We do not believe that women are to be ordained into eldership/leadership in the Church. This role/responsibility (eldership) is to only be undertaken by qualified men.
  • Under the New Covenant, in Christ, men and women are equally gifted. All of the gifts of the Holy Spirit, including the gift of teaching, are available to both men and women. We read about women who were praying and prophesying in the church (1 Cor. 11:5).
  • Under male eldership/leadership in the Church, women can use all the gifts that God has given them, including the gift of teaching. 
  • Male elders lead churches WITH their wives alongside them in partnership. It is therefore accurate to describe a church being led by a couple or couples in the case of a plurality of elders. 
  • Because the responsibility of headship lies with men, the men are accountable for both the success and/or failure of the churches. In the same way, a coach is held responsible for the success/failure of the team he coaches, so too are male elders held responsible for the life of the church. In other words, with the unique authority that God gives qualified men in the Church, so too comes the unique responsibility that follows such a role.
  • We do NOT believe that allowing qualified/gifted women to use all the gifts that men can in the life of the Church (i.e., teaching and preaching) means that some type of doctrinal "slippery slope" will result. Yes, many churches that changed their position on women in ministry have ended up compromising in other doctrinal areas. At the same time, there are many churches that allow women to preach and teach that remain extremely conservative in doctrine and practice.

Because so much has been written in defense of both the Complementarian and the Egalitarian positions, I have opted to NOT cite all the Scriptural support and/or to explain particular interpretations of verses/passages. I would direct the reader to the sources below.

Sources:

1. https://www.leadbiblically.com/understanding-the-spectrum-of-complementarianism/

2. https://ericgeiger.com/2023/06/20/soft-complementarians-holding-to-headship-and-the-gifting-of-women/

3. https://ericgeiger.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/WomenInLeadership_v3.pdf

4. https://www.wholereason.com/2015/05/why-i-am-a-complemenatarian.html


Comments